Tuesday, January 17, 2017

Oranges To Oranges






POLITICO’s Morning Defense: Trump’s NATO critique reverberates across…by Jeremy Herb 1/17/2017 08:30 AM EDT
TRUMP WEIGHS NUKE REDUCTIONS FOR SANCTIONS RELIEF, he says in a Times of London interview, writes our colleague Eli Stokols: "President-elect Donald Trump signaled an openness to working with Russian President Vladimir Putin on a nuclear reduction deal to ease American sanctions



My Voice by Catherine Galbreath

Dear President-Elect Trump,

It boils down to 'oranges to oranges.' 

I am writing to give you a lesson in how to use international relations (sanctions in this case) to the benefit of the United States not Russia. I will keep it very simple.

Part One

In 2014 Russia annexed the Crimea, part of the sovereign state of the Ukraine.

The United States and allies assessed sanctions against Russia.
Sanctions were three pronged:
  1. access was denied to western financial markets and their services
  2. an embargo was set on exports on high-tech oil exploration and production equipment
  3. an embargo was set on exports of select military and dual-use items
The sanctions are having their desired effect. 
The price of oil has fallen.
There has been downward pressure on the Rouble. 
Russia had to use some of their foreign exchange reserves to shore up sanctioned entities. 
The Central Bank was forced to hike interest rates.
The country went into a recession.

The US and it’s allies worked in a cooperative effort to exact sanctions.
The sanctions hit Russia in it’s pocketbook.
With a recession, Russia cannot expand it’s economy or improve it’s standing abroad. 
Russia lost it’s $500 billion deal with Exxon/Mobil to drill in Siberian Arctic.

The stance of the US and Allies is that the sanctions will stay in place until Russia gets out of the Crimea and restores the territory to the Ukraine. PERIOD

This is how sanctions work. 
Sanctions are meant to have real and meaningful consequences. 
Sanctions are meant to hurt. 
Sanctions are meant to force change.

Sanctions are applied for a particular reason. They are not applied “just because we can.” 
Using sanctions is a show of force and strength by the United States and allies.
It is not a negotiation. The parties are not equal.

Part Two

Negotiations on nuclear weapons have progressed over time and sources of enriched uranium have been curtailed. But there is more work to do, of course. We are currently under the New START agreement started 2011. This agreement should be fulfilled by both nations by 2018.
Up to now, the United States has been able to verify what it has negotiated utilizing various intelligence methods.

Negotiating any kind of agreement takes a huge array of specialized talent and skillful negotiators. It is extremely complicated with many 'moving parts.' Our goals and policies have to be studied extensively before a course of action can be taken. Our treaties have been negotiated by two parties energized to arrive at a mutually beneficial outcome that is transparent and verifiable. 

Part Three

Sanctions, however, are not negotiated. They are imposed by the US.
Sanctions are a powerful diplomatic tool in our arsenal of persuasion.

Why would you want to “signal an openness to working with Russian President Vladimir Putin on a nuclear reduction deal to ease American sanctions” when the two issues are not mutually beneficial, nor are they equally important to the US strategically. 

The playing field has to be equal such as: We want to reduce nuclear weapons, you want to reduce nuclear weapons.

Not, we want to reduce nuclear weapons and you want to reduce sanctions. That does not equate as equal.  It needs to be oranges for oranges and apples for apples. Warhead for warhead, not warhead for sanction. 

Putin wants to lift sanctions more than he wants to reduce nuclear weapons. 
Just ask Rex Tillerson why. Just ask Exxon/Mobil why.

Remember negotiations need to be mutually beneficial.

Do not take away and make meaningless one of our most potent tools of diplomacy. If the US lifts sanctions without getting their intended results, what is that saying to Russia? We want to maintain the use of sanctions for other times and situations. We do not want to negotiate away our ability to use sanctions - ever.

The Department of State has some briefing books you and your staff might want to read before taking any actions abroad. They have some very clear guidelines on how to use American POWER diplomatically. You might want to study those before you make a date with PUTIE.

On behalf of my grandsons,

Catherine

p.s. The administration would not want to adopt and announce actions and policies that looked like they ignored or rewarded Russia’s recent bad behavior. (1)


1. Pifer, Steven, Nuclear modernization, arms control, and U.S.-Russia relations, Washington, D.C., Brookings.edu, 2016


No comments:

Post a Comment